How the scorecard behaves on an anchor text backlink
The first two lines matter most. They decide whether your anchor can read like part of the article.
Take an example with invented numbers. Row A is a 1,800-word piece on onboarding emails, DR 52, with a sentence about "drip sequences" in the third paragraph. Row B is DR 61, a list of forty tools, no copy around any of them. A scores 14. B scores 7, because the metrics line is the only one that wins.
That is the whole point. Authority numbers are one line out of eight, and the other seven describe what a visitor sees. Ahrefs and Semrush give you a second opinion on the host domain if you want one, while our list shows DR, organic traffic and referring domains per row.
Run the scorecard on the host article, not the homepage of the host site. A site can carry a good page and a poor one.
One more habit helps. Keep the scores in a sheet with the date, because a host article that scored 13 in October 2026 can lose points if the page changes next spring.
Treat the sheet as a shared note for the whole content team, so nobody pays for the same weak row twice.